On this page
Thanksgiving in Canada falls on Monday, October 12, 2026. If you are hosting, the grocery bill can climb quickly: turkey, sides, pies, drinks and snacks. With a little planning, you can put a full, traditional dinner on the table for much less.
The short answer: plan your menu two weeks ahead, buy the turkey by comparing price per pound, buy potatoes, butter and apples when they hit their low prices, make most dishes from scratch with pantry staples, and ask guests to bring a side or dessert.
Step 1: Plan the menu now
Write the full menu with quantities. A classic Thanksgiving for eight might include:
- Roast turkey
- Mashed potatoes
- Stuffing
- Gravy
- Roasted carrots or squash
- A green vegetable
- Cranberry sauce
- Rolls
- Apple or pumpkin pie
Check which ingredients you already have. Many sides share the same basics: butter, onions, potatoes, flour, broth.
Step 2: Buy the turkey by price per pound
The turkey is usually the biggest cost. Plan about 1 lb of whole, bone-in turkey per person, or 1.5 lb if you want leftovers. For eight people with leftovers, that is about 12 lb.
Compare prices per pound across stores. For example, a 12 lb turkey at $1.49 per pound is about $18, while at $2.99 per pound it is about $36.
If you buy frozen, allow time to thaw it in the fridge. A common guideline is about one day for every 2 kg (4 to 5 lb). Follow the package instructions.
Step 3: Potatoes at their low price
Mashed potatoes are cheap if you buy the right bag. In Ontario flyers from April to September 2026:
- 10 lb bags were as low as $1.99 at No Frills (weeks of July 30 and September 10) and $2.00 to $2.50 at several other stores in their best weeks.
- Many flyer prices were $3.99 to $5.00 for 10 lb.
- Some 5 lb bags were $5.99, or $1.20 a pound.
For eight people, about 4 lb of potatoes is plenty. A 10 lb bag at $1.99 covers dinner for about 80 cents and leaves extra for the week.
Step 4: Butter, now
You will use butter in the mashed potatoes, stuffing, rolls, gravy and pie. From April to September 2026, most Ontario flyer prices for a 454 g block were $4.88 to $5.99, and stock-up prices were $4.00 or less. Buy two or three blocks at a good price and freeze what you do not need yet.
Step 5: Seasonal produce for sides and pie
Fall produce is at its cheapest right now:
- Apples: loose Gala and McIntosh were as low as 99 cents a pound in Ontario flyers in September 2026. Apple pie or crisp is one of the cheapest desserts you can make.
- Carrots, onions and squash: often at their lowest price in the fall. Look for big bags.
- Cranberries: fresh cranberries make a cheap homemade sauce with sugar and water.
Step 6: Make it from scratch
Homemade versions of many sides cost much less than prepared ones:
- Stuffing: day-old bread, onion, celery, butter and herbs
- Gravy: pan drippings, flour and broth
- Cranberry sauce: cranberries, sugar, water
- Pie crust: flour, butter, salt and water
If time is short, buy one prepared item (like pie shells) and make the rest.
Where the money usually goes
For most hosts, the turkey is the single biggest cost, followed by butter, dairy and dessert. Prepared sides, specialty cheeses and drinks can quietly add as much as the turkey itself. If you need to trim, start with the extras, not the basics: one good dessert instead of three, and a simple cheese plate instead of several specialty items.
Step 7: Share the load
Hosting does not mean paying for everything. Ask guests to bring a side, a dessert or drinks. Most people are happy to contribute, and it gives the dinner more variety.
Step 8: Plan the leftovers
A good Thanksgiving budget includes the week after:
- Turkey sandwiches and wraps
- Turkey soup from the carcass
- Leftover mashed potatoes in shepherd's pie
- Frozen portions of turkey for later meals
Refrigerate leftovers within two hours and follow food-safety guidance on how long to keep them.
A two-week shopping plan
| When | What to buy |
|---|---|
| Two weeks before | Butter, flour, sugar, broth, canned pumpkin, frozen turkey if the price is right |
| One week before | Potatoes, onions, carrots, squash, apples, cranberries |
| Three to four days before | Fresh herbs, green vegetables, rolls, cream |
| Thaw timing | Frozen turkey into the fridge based on its weight |
Let FlyerHawk find the Thanksgiving deals
The week before Thanksgiving, prices for turkey and sides change quickly. FlyerHawk tracks the flyers near you, compares each price with its normal range and alerts you when it is a real deal. Try FlyerHawk free for 14 days and add your Thanksgiving list today.
FAQ
How can I save money on Thanksgiving dinner?
Plan early, buy the turkey by price per pound, buy staples like potatoes and butter at their low prices, make sides from scratch, and ask guests to bring a dish.
How much turkey do I need for eight people?
About 8 lb without leftovers, or about 12 lb with leftovers, based on a common guideline of 1 to 1.5 lb per person.
When is Thanksgiving in 2026?
Thanksgiving in Canada is on Monday, October 12, 2026.
What is the cheapest Thanksgiving dessert?
Apple crisp or apple pie made with in-season apples is usually one of the cheapest options.
